Image source: AP Photo/Jacob Kupferman
Darian Mensah’s attempt to leave Duke has reached a pivotal moment as both sides explore a possible settlement instead of letting the case drag through the courts, according to attorney Rob Weaver (source: Weaver analysis).
Weaver believes Duke has every incentive to settle the dispute with Darian Mensah. “I would be very surprised if Duke doesn’t reach a settlement with Mensah,” he wrote, arguing that the January 29 preliminary injunction hearing is a “lose-lose” scenario for the school.
He explained that the legal fight is not about Darian Mensah returning to Duke or the school collecting major monetary damages. According to Weaver, those outcomes are essentially already determined.
Right now, Darian Mensah cannot enroll at another university, which increases time pressure. Every delay hurts his ability to land elsewhere before spring semesters and football activities begin.
The backstory behind this NIL conflict is notable. After a breakout 2024 season at Tulane, Darian Mensah signed a two-year NIL deal with Duke worth $4 million per year, according to court filings.
That agreement reportedly prohibited Mensah from enrolling at another school, playing college football elsewhere, or using his NIL rights outside of Duke during the contract term. When Darian Mensah entered the transfer portal anyway, Duke responded immediately.
On January 20, Duke filed for arbitration and sought a temporary restraining order to stop him from moving. A Durham County Superior Court judge granted the TRO the following day, blocking Darian Mensah from enrolling, playing, or using his NIL rights at another school.
Mensah’s camp countered by filing an emergency motion to reconsider the TRO and pushed to accelerate the timeline. The original February 2 hearing date was moved up as a result.
Duke officially placed Darian Mensah in the transfer portal after midnight on January 21, but the TRO remains active until the preliminary injunction hearing on January 29.
At that hearing, Duke must prove it would suffer “irreparable harm” if Darian Mensah is allowed to leave despite his signed NIL contract.
Weaver warned that the outcome could reshape college sports. “If Duke loses the PI hearing, threats of enjoining athletes breaching their agreements will ring hollow. If Duke wins, athletes will get precariously close to being viewed as employees,” he noted.
Even if a settlement occurs, Weaver argues Duke would still claim an important symbolic victory. They would remain the first school to secure a TRO against a player in an NIL dispute, sending a serious warning to future athletes about breaching deals.
The Darian Mensah case is also part of a much larger national trend. The NIL era has opened the door to legal fights between schools and student-athletes that would have been unthinkable before 2021.
For example, Washington quarterback Demond Williams signed a $4 million retention deal, then attempted to transfer four days later. Washington threatened legal action, and Williams stayed.
Wisconsin went further and actually sued Miami for alleged tampering involving defensive back Xavier Lucas, who left despite a revenue-sharing agreement.
Georgia also pursued $390,000 in damages from former player Damon Wilson after he transferred to Missouri, claiming he violated his NIL contract.
Darian Mensah’s situation is different because Duke is attempting to enforce exclusive NIL rights that they believe they legally purchased. If courts uphold Duke’s stance, schools could use NIL contracts as binding tools to restrict athlete movement.
If Duke loses, NIL agreements may weaken, giving athletes more mobility than ever.
Either way, the Darian Mensah case may become the example future courts and schools look to when deciding how much power NIL deals truly carry.
For now, the entire college football world is watching to see whether this ends in a settlement—or sets a new legal standard.
FAQ:
Who is Darian Mensah?
Darian Mensah is a college football quarterback who had a breakout season at Tulane in 2024 before signing a major NIL deal with Duke.
Why is Darian Mensah in a legal dispute with Duke?
The dispute started when Darian Mensah tried to enter the transfer portal even though his NIL contract with Duke reportedly prevented him from enrolling or playing elsewhere during the deal.
What is Duke asking the court to do?
Duke requested a temporary restraining order (TRO) and a preliminary injunction to stop Darian Mensah from joining another school or using his NIL rights until the case is resolved.
What is a temporary restraining order (TRO) in this context?
A TRO is an emergency court order that blocks someone from taking action. In this case, it temporarily blocks Mensah from enrolling at a different school or using NIL deals elsewhere.
What is a preliminary injunction hearing?
It’s a hearing where the court decides if the restrictions should stay in place longer. Duke must prove it would suffer “irreparable harm” if Darian Mensah leaves.
Can Darian Mensah enroll at another school right now?
No. Because of the TRO, he cannot enroll, play, or use his NIL rights at another college until the court makes a decision or the sides reach a settlement.
Did Darian Mensah enter the transfer portal?
Yes. Duke officially entered his name into the transfer portal, but the TRO still limits what he can do while the case continues.
Why is this Duke NIL case important for college sports?
This case could set a precedent for how NIL contracts are enforced. It may determine whether schools can legally block athletes from transferring based on NIL deals.
Could this case make college athletes look more like employees?
Some legal experts, including attorney Rob Weaver, say a Duke victory could push courts to view athletes as employees because they are bound by exclusive contracts.
Is a settlement between Duke and Darian Mensah likely?
According to legal analysis, both sides may have reasons to settle. A settlement would avoid further court battles and still give Duke symbolic leverage moving forward.
How does this case compare to other NIL disputes?
Several schools, including Washington, Wisconsin, and Georgia, have used legal threats or lawsuits in NIL disputes. The Darian Mensah case stands out because it focuses on exclusive NIL rights and transfer restrictions.
What could happen next in the Darian Mensah case?
There are two main options: Duke settles with Mensah, or the court rules on the injunction. Either outcome could influence future NIL contracts and transfer portal rules.
Also Read: Tristan Smith and Trinidad Chambliss Highlight NCAA Eligibility Chaos
