Is This the Real Reason the Browns Traded Myles Garrett to the Rams?

The Cleveland Browns have finally made one of the toughest decisions in franchise history, and it all traces back to one move: the Deshaun Watson trade. By sending superstar pass rusher Myles Garrett to the Los Angeles Rams in exchange for rising edge defender Jared Verse, a 2027 first-round pick, and additional draft assets, Cleveland has signaled that a full reset may be underway. It’s a painful move for Browns fans, but it may also be the clearest sign yet that the organization is accepting reality.

For a franchise still trying to escape years of quarterback instability, this trade feels less like a bold gamble and more like a necessary course correction.

The Cost of the Watson Gamble Keeps Growing

When the Browns acquired Deshaun Watson and handed him a fully guaranteed $230 million contract, the expectation was simple: find a franchise quarterback and compete for championships.

Instead, injuries, off-field controversies, and inconsistent performances turned what was supposed to be a franchise-defining move into one of the NFL’s biggest disappointments. Now, years later, the ripple effects are still being felt.

Trading Myles Garrett is the latest consequence. The Browns aren’t moving a declining veteran; they’re parting with arguably the best player they’ve had since returning to the NFL in 1999. That’s not a decision teams make lightly.

In fact, most general managers would rather trade away their office coffee machine than a player like Garrett.

Why Moving Garrett Makes Sense

As dominant as Garrett has been, even elite pass rushers can only influence a game so much. Quarterbacks drive success in today’s NFL, and Cleveland still doesn’t have a long-term answer at the position.

The Browns won just eight games over the past two seasons despite Garrett continuing to terrorize opposing offensive lines. His individual brilliance often wasn’t enough to overcome the team’s bigger issues.

One of the clearest examples came when Garrett recorded five sacks against the New England Patriots last season. The Browns still lost by 19 points.

That’s the harsh reality of modern football: a great quarterback can change a franchise, while even a generational defensive player can’t do it alone.

A New Focus on the Future

By acquiring Jared Verse and valuable draft capital, Cleveland is giving itself more flexibility for the future. The additional 2027 first-round pick could become a crucial asset in a quarterback-rich draft class.

The move also suggests the Browns remain unconvinced that Shedeur Sanders is their long-term solution under center. If the organization truly believed it had already found its future quarterback, keeping Garrett would have made far more sense.

Instead, Cleveland appears to be gathering resources for another swing at finding the most important player on the field.

For Browns fans, that probably feels like hearing “rebuilding” for the hundredth time. Unfortunately, the franchise’s history has provided plenty of practice.

Garrett Wanted to Win — And He Was Honest About It

Garrett never hid his desire to compete for championships. Throughout his career, he repeatedly expressed his commitment to winning and his reluctance to spend his prime years stuck in mediocrity.

His concerns weren’t unfounded. Despite being one of the NFL’s most feared defenders, the Browns struggled to build a consistent contender around him.

Many observers compared his situation to that of Hall of Fame offensive tackle Joe Thomas, another Browns legend whose individual greatness rarely translated into team success. Garrett made it clear he didn’t want that same story to define his career.

Now he’ll get a fresh opportunity elsewhere, while Cleveland starts planning for its next chapter.

Pressure Mounts on Andrew Berry

General manager Andrew Berry now faces perhaps the biggest challenge of his career. He was already heavily criticized for helping orchestrate the Watson deal. Now he’s also the executive who authorized trading away the franchise’s best player in decades.

The success or failure of this move will ultimately depend on what happens next.

If the Browns use their growing collection of draft assets to finally land a franchise quarterback, the Garrett trade could eventually be viewed as a painful but necessary turning point. If they miss again, it will become another painful chapter in a franchise that has seen too many of them.

The Myles Garrett trade marks the end of an era in Cleveland and highlights just how deeply the Deshaun Watson experiment has impacted the Browns. Losing a player of Garrett’s caliber is never easy, but the organization appears to recognize that its biggest problem remains unsolved.

Until Cleveland finds a quarterback it truly believes can lead the franchise into the future, every other roster decision becomes secondary. The Garrett trade may be heartbreaking for fans today, but the Browns are betting it helps them find the answer they’ve been searching for all along.

Whether that gamble pays off is a question that won’t be answered for several seasons. For now, one thing is certain: the Watson saga continues to reshape the Browns in ways few could have imagined.

FAQ:

Also Read: Why Are Ohio State and Tennessee Fighting for David Gabriel Georges?

👉 If you like our content, please click here and add us as your preferred source. It helps us a lot, and we are committed to delivering you the very latest sports news.